Encumbrances and Liens

Encumbrances and liens are interests that burden someone else's property without giving them possession. They are tested on every real estate license exam. This guide covers easements (appurtenant, in gross and by prescription), encroachments, licenses, deed restrictions, lien types and priority, foreclosure and redemption rights – with practice questions at the end.

Quick Answer

An encumbrance is any claim that limits an owner's rights without giving possession. It either restricts use (easements, deed restrictions, encroachments) or affects title with a money claim (liens). Property tax liens usually come first in priority; most other liens follow first in time, first in right.

Overview of Encumbrances

An encumbrance is a non-possessory interest, claim, or charge held by someone other than the legal property owner that burdens, diminishes, or limits the owner's freehold bundle of rights. Because an encumbrance does not grant the right of physical possession, it is legally classified as an interest rather than an estate in land.

Encumbrances fall into two broad functional categories on real estate examinations:

  • Encumbrances that Restrict Physical Use: Non-monetary burdens that define how the physical property may or may not be used. Examples include easements, encroachments, deed restrictions, and licenses.
  • Encumbrances that Affect Title and Financial Value (Liens): Monetary claims secured against the real estate as financial collateral for an unpaid debt. If the underlying obligation is not satisfied, a lien grants the creditor the legal right to force a judicial or public sale through foreclosure.

Easements: Appurtenant, Gross & Prescriptive

An easement is a legal interest in real property (not revocable at will, unlike a license) granting the holder the right to use a designated portion of another party's land for a specific, defined purpose (such as a driveway access road or underground utility pipe).

1. Easement Appurtenant

An easement appurtenant directly benefits an adjacent parcel of real estate and attaches permanently to the land (it "runs with the land"). It requires two distinct tracts of land owned by two separate parties:

Tenement Type Legal Status Impact on Property Value
Dominant Tenement
(Dominant Estate)
The property that enjoys and benefits from the easement usage. (e.g., the landlocked tract using an access road). The easement attaches as an appurtenance, increasing utility and marketable value. Automatically conveys with deed upon resale.
Servient Tenement
(Servient Estate)
The property that is burdened by the easement and must allow the dominant owner's use. The easement constitutes an encumbrance on title. The servient owner may also use the easement area as long as it does not obstruct the dominant use.

Common forms of easement appurtenant include:

  • Easement by Necessity: Granted by a court of law when a parcel is legally landlocked with no access to a public thoroughfare. The law recognizes an implied grant because public policy opposes leaving real estate landlocked and unusable.
  • Party Wall Easement: A shared perimeter wall or fence straddling a boundary line between two adjoining buildings. Each owner owns their half in severalty and holds an easement appurtenant across the other half for structural support.

2. Easement in Gross

Unlike an easement appurtenant, an easement in gross does not attach to or benefit any adjoining parcel of land. There is only a servient tenement (the burdened land); there is NO dominant estate. Easements in gross exist in two legal forms:

  • Personal Easement in Gross: Granted to an individual for their personal lifetime. It is irrevocable during the holder's life, but terminates upon the death of the grantee. It cannot be sold, assigned, or willed. (Example: Permission granted to a neighbor to cross your oceanfront lot to fish).
  • Commercial Easement in Gross: Granted to a corporate or municipal entity to conduct commercial operations. It can be freely sold, assigned, or transferred. (Examples: Overhead electric utility lines, municipal water mains, petroleum pipelines, railroad rights-of-way).
Exam Key: Appurtenant vs. Gross

Question: An electric power company holds a right-of-way across 50 suburban lots to maintain power lines. What type of easement is this?
Answer: A Commercial Easement in Gross! Because the easement benefits a company rather than an adjacent parcel of land, there is no dominant tenement.

3. Easement by Prescription (Prescriptive Easement)

An easement by prescription is acquired through the unauthorized, adverse use of another's real estate for a statutory period of years (the length is set by state law and varies by state). To earn a prescriptive easement in court, the claimant's usage must satisfy four legal conditions remembered by the acronym POACH:

  • P - Possession: Actual use of the land, the way an owner would use it.
  • O - Open and Notorious: Obvious and visible so that a reasonable owner inspecting their land would discover it.
  • A - Adverse: Used without the owner's permission or license.
  • C - Continuous: Uninterrupted throughout the entire statutory timeline.
  • H - Hostile: Under claim of right, adverse to the legal owner's title.

How Easements Terminate

Easements do not terminate merely through owner preference. Legal termination occurs only through:

  • Express Release: The dominant tenement holder signs a formal quitclaim deed releasing the easement back to the servient owner.
  • Merger of Title: If the same owner acquires title to both the dominant and servient parcels, the easement is extinguished automatically (one cannot hold an easement on one's own property).
  • Abandonment: Requires physical, overt action by the dominant owner demonstrating clear intent never to use the easement again.
  • Destruction or Cessation of Purpose: If the underlying necessity ends (e.g., a new public highway provides direct road access to a formerly landlocked parcel).

Encroachments and Licenses

Encroachments

An encroachment is the unauthorized, physical intrusion of an improvement, fixture, or natural object across a legal boundary line onto an adjoining neighbor's real property. Typical examples include a driveway paved 2 feet over the lot line, a boundary fence installed off-line, or the eave of a roof extending into adjacent airspace.

Encroachments are physical trespasses and rarely appear on standard public title records. They are typically uncovered during a professional spot survey prior to closing. If an encroached landowner fails to demand removal within the state statutory timeframe, the encroachment can ripen into an easement by prescription.

Licenses

A license is a personal, temporary, and revocable privilege granted by a property owner to enter the premises for a specific purpose without creating an interest in real estate.

  • Revocable at Will: The landowner can cancel the license at any moment without cause.
  • Non-Transferable: Licenses cannot be assigned, sold, or willed.
  • Terminates on Death or Sale: A license automatically terminates upon the death of either party or upon the sale of the real property.
  • Examples: A hunting permit on private timberland, a verbal invitation to park on a driveway, or a ticket to a concert or sporting event.

Deed Restrictions (CC&Rs) vs. Zoning

A deed restriction (or restrictive covenant) is a private limitation placed in a deed of conveyance or recorded subdivision plat by a developer or grantor to control how future owners use the property. Common examples include minimum home square footage, architectural facade standards, setback distances, and prohibitions against detached sheds or parked commercial trucks.

Deed restrictions take two legal forms:

  • Covenants: Mutual promises running with the land. If breached, adjoining homeowners or the HOA may petition the court for an injunction forcing compliance, or sue for monetary damages. Title is not forfeited.
  • Conditions: Tied directly to ownership conveyance. If breached, the grantor may initiate legal action to declare forfeiture and repossess the real estate (as in fee simple defeasible estates).
Golden Exam Rule: Deed Restrictions vs. Zoning Ordinances

When private deed restrictions and public municipal zoning ordinances conflict, THE STRICTEST RULE ALWAYS APPLIES! For instance, if municipal zoning permits a building setback of 15 feet, but subdivision CC&Rs mandate a 25-foot setback, the homeowner must comply with the 25-foot deed restriction.

Liens: Types, Creation & Priority Rules

A lien is a creditor's statutory or equitable financial claim against real property held as security for the payment of a debt or financial obligation. The creditor who holds the lien is the lienor; the property owner whose title is burdened is the lienee.

Lien Classifications

Lien Classification Legal Definition Primary Real Estate Examples
Voluntary Lien Created with the contractual consent and signature of the property owner. Mortgage liens, Home Equity Lines of Credit (HELOCs), Deeds of Trust.
Involuntary Lien Imposed by law or judicial statute without owner consent. Real estate property tax liens, mechanic's liens, judgment liens.
Specific Lien Attaches only to one specific, designated parcel of real estate. Ad valorem property tax lien, special assessment, mortgage, mechanic's lien.
General Lien Attaches to all of the debtor's property (a judgment lien attaches to real estate in each county where it is recorded). Federal IRS income tax liens, state income tax liens, court judgment liens, inheritance tax liens.

Lien Priority: Who Gets Paid First?

When a property is foreclosed and sold, the sales proceeds are distributed strictly according to Lien Priority:

  1. SUPER PRIORITY (Always Paid First): Real Estate Property Taxes (Ad Valorem Taxes) and Special Assessment Liens automatically take senior priority over ALL other liens, regardless of when other liens were recorded!
  2. Mechanic's Liens: In many states, a mechanic's lien takes priority based on the date physical work began or materials were first delivered to the site, rather than when the lien was formally filed in the courthouse records.
  3. All Other Liens: Governed by the universal rule: "First in time, first in right"—priority is established strictly by the date and time of recordation in county public land records. (A lender can agree to voluntarily subordinate their priority through a Subordination Agreement).

Foreclosure Mechanics and Rights of Redemption

If a borrower defaults on a secured mortgage or tax debt, the lienholder can enforce liquidation through foreclosure. Three primary legal procedures exist:

  • Judicial Foreclosure: Common in lien-theory states that use mortgages. The lender files a formal lawsuit in court. The court issues a decree of sale, and the county sheriff auctions the property to the highest bidder at a public sheriff's sale.
  • Non-Judicial Foreclosure (Power of Sale): Used where the deed of trust or mortgage has a power-of-sale clause (common with deeds of trust). The trustee conducts a public auction without court supervision after delivering statutory default notice.
  • Strict Foreclosure: The court grants direct legal title to the lender without a public foreclosure auction.

Equitable vs. Statutory Right of Redemption

Real estate licensing exams heavily test the borrower's rights to reclaim their property during foreclosure:

Redemption Period When it Occurs How the Borrower Redeems
Equitable Right of Redemption BEFORE the foreclosure sale takes place. (From notice of default up to the courthouse auction gavel). Borrower pays the delinquent payments, accrued interest, penalties, and legal costs to stop the foreclosure.
Statutory Right of Redemption AFTER the foreclosure sale has concluded. (Only in states that allow it; the window varies, often up to a year or more). Borrower pays the winning auction bidder the full purchase price plus statutory interest to reclaim deed title.

Key Exam Takeaways

Master these essential summary points before taking practice exams on encumbrances and liens:

  • Encumbrance Definition: A non-possessory claim or burden that limits an owner's rights or property value.
  • Easement Appurtenant: Benefits the dominant tenement; burdens the servient tenement. Runs with the land automatically upon conveyance.
  • Easement in Gross: Has a servient tenement but NO dominant tenement. Commercial gross easements (utilities) are assignable and perpetual; personal gross easements expire upon grantee's death.
  • Prescriptive Easement (POACH): Acquired through Possession, Open, Adverse, Continuous, and Hostile use over the statutory term.
  • License vs. Easement: A license is personal, revocable, and non-assignable; an easement is an irrevocable property interest.
  • Encroachment: Physical boundary intrusion; detected through a spot survey.
  • Rule of Strictness: When private CC&Rs conflict with municipal zoning, the stricter rule always governs.
  • Lien Seniority: Real estate property taxes and special assessments ALWAYS take priority over all mortgages and judgments. All other liens follow recording date order ("first in time, first in right").
  • Redemption Timeline: Equitable redemption is before the foreclosure sale; statutory redemption is after the foreclosure sale.

Encumbrances & Liens Practice Questions

Test yourself with these exam-style questions. Choose your answer, then open the explanation.

1. A power company's right to run lines across many lots is an:

  • A. Easement appurtenant
  • B. Commercial easement in gross
  • C. License
  • D. Encroachment
Show answer

Answer: B. It benefits a company, not a neighboring parcel, so it is a commercial easement in gross.

2. Zoning requires a 15-foot setback; the subdivision CC&Rs require 25 feet. The owner must follow:

  • A. 15 feet
  • B. 25 feet
  • C. 20 feet
  • D. Whichever the owner picks
Show answer

Answer: B. When private and public rules conflict, the stricter rule applies.

3. Which is a general lien?

  • A. Mortgage
  • B. Property tax lien
  • C. Judgment lien
  • D. Mechanic's lien
Show answer

Answer: C. A judgment lien can attach to all of the debtor's property (for real estate, in counties where it is recorded).

4. A neighbor's fence sits 2 feet onto your lot. This is:

  • A. An easement
  • B. An encroachment
  • C. A license
  • D. A lien
Show answer

Answer: B. A physical intrusion over the property line is an encroachment.

5. An easement ends when one person buys both the dominant and servient parcels. This is termination by:

  • A. Abandonment
  • B. Merger
  • C. Release
  • D. Prescription
Show answer

Answer: B. You can't hold an easement over your own land, so merger ends it.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between an easement appurtenant and an easement in gross?

An easement appurtenant benefits a neighboring parcel (the dominant tenement) and runs with the land. An easement in gross benefits a person or company, such as a utility, and has no dominant tenement.

What is the difference between an easement and a license?

An easement is an interest in land. A license is personal permission that can usually be revoked at any time.

Which liens are paid first after foreclosure?

Property tax and special assessment liens generally come first. Most other liens are paid by recording date.

What is the difference between equitable and statutory redemption?

Equitable redemption happens before the foreclosure sale; statutory redemption, where available, happens after the sale.

Who is the lienor and who is the lienee?

The lienor is the creditor who holds the lien. The lienee is the property owner whose property is burdened.

Sources

Key rules on this page were checked against these sources in October 2026. Laws and fees change and vary by state, so confirm with your state's licensing agency.